Ramadan Eaters Protest - Instablogs
Ramadan Eaters Protest
Mohammed Taha , BS: Sep 19 2009
Made Popular Sep 21 2009
Morocco :

Ramadan Eaters Protest

Since Morocco is a Muslim country, breaking the rules of fasting is against the law and the punishment can be one to six months in prison and fines at almost 100 dollars, according to Article 222 of the Moroccan Penal Code. However, a group of protesters calling themselves as MALI (the movement for defence of individual liberties) had attempted to break their Ramadan fasting in a public place to express their objection to this law. The protesters met up in a train station in Mohammedia city and once they showed the food the police forced them to go back to Casablanca where they came from.

In my opinion, I think everyone is free to believe in whatever he wants. If they don’t want to fast then it’s something between them and their God (in case they believe in God) but to provoke all
Muslims and insult their religion by eating during Ramadan in public then it’s a stupid and disrespectful way to express their protest to the fasting law. Strange enough, a lot of Europeans reporters came to Morocco to support the protest and condemned the Moroccan authorities for forcing the Ramadan eaters to go back home.

The European reporters’ interest in this protest is strange for many reasons among which:

The protesters are all Moroccans and they were breaking the Article 222 of the Moroccan Penal Code and they had the right to arrest them. There are non-muslim people who live in Morocco and they practice their religions freely and no one force them to fast Ramadan.

The protest was within the Moroccan territory so the Moroccan authorities had the right to stop it. European journalists did not defend the right of Muslim women to wear the veil and practice their religion freely.

European journalists supported their countries’ law against Muslims; yet, they run to Morocco to support MALI. To sum up with, such a protest was immature and the European reporters who came to support MALI are a bunch of hypocrites.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Khalid
Rabat, Morocco
I respect the laws of the land here, and am careful not to eat and drink (or even bake delicious things for the smell temptation) so as not to tempt my host country residents.

I think the whole idea of making religious identity a matter of state enforcement is troubling.
1 Stars
well the main religion in Morocco is Islam with more than 99% of muslims in this country so it’s not troubling, besides the King himself derives his authority from being ”Ameer Al-Mumineen”.
the point is, this is an islamic country, one doesn’t have to be a muslim because they are free to believe in whatever they want YET they should respect this country’s religion and culture, as simple as that
thanks a lot for your comment, have a good day ;)
1 Stars
Ibrahim
Cairo, Egypt
I am neither for or against those who want to eat in public during Ramadan because, plain and simple, it's not my business. If I was there and saw them, I would just walk away.

I believe in freedom, and no one should tell me whether I should fast or not, it's my life and it's my choice. So let them be free to express themselves.

I am fasting for me and for Allah. And no one else.
1 Stars
hmm well yeah u have to believe in this way actually since about 10% of egyptians are coptic and they have the right to live their lives without being ”affected” by any other religion which is very difficult, freedom and respect are two different things, I believe in my religion and I do respect others’ and i’d never do something to offend them
happy to talk to you, have a good day and thanks for your comment ;)
1 Stars
Andrew
Melbourne, Australia
You are not supposed to eat in public, just like you are not supposed to take
corruption in public, because both acts do/should provoke the Muslim.
1 Stars
hey Anderw! I completely agree with you, thanks for your comment, have a good day ;)
1 Stars
Ziyad
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
besides being disrespectful to Islam and to Muslims, this initiative is very rude and non tolerant. It shows hate and inability to understand the other.

I suggest that if this group doesn't want to obey the rule, they can always leave and live in a non Muslim Country.
1 Stars
I agree about the first part of your comment. Concerning the living in a non-muslim country, it’s their country as well, they have all the right to live in it freely and protest againt the laws they see as ”unfair” but such a protest is stupid and it has other purposes rather than the fasting law, they just wanted a publicity to their pathetic association. so yeah they have the right to live in their country and the authorities have to arrest/punish anyone who tries to break the law
thanks a lot for your comment, it’s much appreciates, have a blessed day inshallah
salaamu Allaahi alaikum :)
1 Stars
Kevin
Manchester, United Kingdom
Laws should be based on logic and it is clear that some of these laws do not stand the scrutiny of logic and should be reviewed and discarded…
1 Stars
hey Kevin, thanks for your comment, it opens the door to a more interesting topics actually ... law is based on logic, culture, religion and many other stuff, the logic says in a country that more than 99% of its population are muslims then the law has to respect this religion, the best example to prove the stupidity of this kinda protesters is the moroccans’ reaction to such protest
have a good day Mr.Kevin
bye :)
1 Stars
Mathieu
Paris, France
Religion is a personal issue. Those who want to fast they are free to do so and those who want to eat should also be free to do so. Nobody should insult the intelligence of others. After all, if God is great He can defend Himself and He would not wish to be defended by weak human beings, who may think that they are more intelligent than those who do not agree with them.
1 Stars
I agree with you Mathieu.
1 Stars
don’t mind the other comment, it was not mine anyhow ... religion is indeed a personal issue but when to offend the whole moroccans and break the law of the country they voted for its constitution then its not a personal issue.
thanks a lot for your comment,
prend soin de toi, bye :)
1 Stars
Hey Tea,
I really am longing for the day when people start respecting each other out of respect rather than bcz there’s a law that says we have to do it...
I work in a place where almost 50% of the employees and management are christians, there’s no law against ”no eating” in ramadan, and my coworkers still ask me if its OK for them to drink their morning coffee or eat their lunch when Im around in the staff room or the kitchen. why can’t we all care about each other a bit more and care less for what we would get punished for if we don’t obey?!!!
1 Stars
that’s because your christian co-workers are sensitive human beings and respect the cultural diversity in where you live. thanks a lot dafty :S
lol sorry just felt like being mean to you, catcha later silly goose
*winks modestly lol
1 Stars
thanks all for your valuable comments, it’s really nice to discuss with others and learn from their opinions.

the problem is not in forcing others to fast or not, but to offend others is kinda a stupid thing to do. In Morocco, there is a jewish minority that lives here, like less than 1000 people or so and even though there is a special law just for them and they practice their religion freely and ironically, u never hear such minorities protesting against fasting law, they know how to respect other religions the same way their neighbors respect theirs
Add your Comment